A recent conversation with friends brought back something that happened with my ex years ago. She once asked me about having a threesome, and I gave what I thought was a pretty unmistakable answer: no. An emphatic no. I didn’t think I’d left much room for interpretation.
Then, a few months later, she asked again.
That bothered me more than the original question. The first time, she was asking about something we hadn’t discussed. By the second time, I thought she already knew how I felt. Hearing it again made me wonder whether she’d understood my answer as a temporary objection instead of a firm limit.
I told her it didn’t matter who the third person might be. There wasn’t a particular combination that would make me interested. I was upset that we were having the conversation again, and I said so.
I don’t know exactly what she intended by asking twice. What I do know is that it affected how I felt about the relationship. I was considering breaking up over it back then, although we eventually split for different reasons. I don’t want to rewrite our breakup around this one issue, but it was significant to me.
Now I’m wondering whether I should make this clear much earlier when I’m dating someone. And I mean the whole subject of nonmonogamy, not just threesomes. I want a monogamous relationship. I’m not waiting for the right person to persuade me to try another arrangement.
There’s something awkward about bringing up a firm limit before anyone has suggested crossing it. I don’t want an early dating conversation to sound like I’m arguing with my ex all over again. At the same time, I’d rather know whether someone wants the same kind of relationship before we’re deeply involved.
That’s the question the conversation with my friends left me with: how early do I say this? I want my next partner to hear a clear answer, and I want to feel confident that we both understand what it means.
