At one in the morning, I picked up my boyfriend’s phone to turn off the LED lights, something I do every night. Messages from another woman were coming in. I opened them. I hadn’t gone through his phone before, and I know turning off the lights didn’t give me permission to read his conversations.
But I did read them. There was talk of using her imagination, followed by a suggestive comment about him hugging his pillow, with a smirk. When I asked him about it, he said she worked in corporate and had no imagination. He said they were only talking because it was her birthday.
Her birthday had been weeks earlier. There were also saved pictures of them together in the chat. He said she was an old school friend. When I asked whether she knew he had a girlfriend, he said, “Obviously.” Had he told her? His answer was that he’d posted me before.
Then I found thousands of saved explicit images on Instagram and what looked like roughly 500 pornography tabs in a hidden browser section. Three years ago, we broke up over what he described as an addiction. When we got back together, he promised he wouldn’t watch it again. Every month, he’s told me he hasn’t.
He said the tabs were old. But some Instagram images had been saved yesterday. When I brought that up, he said it was something he used to do and was stopping. I couldn’t make that explanation fit the dates in front of me.
There was also a message asking whether another woman would meet him at a Halloween party. Apparently, she hadn’t replied. I don’t know whether he has cheated. I’m frightened by what these conversations might mean, but I don’t have an answer to that.
I apologized for going through his phone. He turned away and went back on it. He didn’t apologize. The next morning, he barely spoke before work. Usually, he says he loves me and kisses me goodbye. That morning, he didn’t want to kiss me.
I’m 24, he’s 25, and we’ve been together for four years, apart from that breakup. I’m afraid of becoming insecure in a relationship where I keep discovering things he says aren’t happening. I also stay with him on the days I go into the office, so deciding what comes next has a practical side.
I feel guilty about opening the messages. I’m hurt by what I found and by the lack of accountability afterward. Now I’m trying to work out whether I can stay—and where I’ll stay on my next office day if I can’t.
