My first college party was a Halloween party with my club. I arrived with limited social confidence and no particular romantic ambitions. One of my friends apparently felt this left an opening in the evening’s schedule.
He asked whether I was interested in anyone. I said, “No, not really.” He suggested a woman he thought would be a good match, then walked off. I assumed we had finished discussing it. In retrospect, I may have been the only person who did.
I spent the night talking to pretty much everyone, including her. She was cool and funny. We had a normal conversation, and I didn’t feel a romantic connection. Nothing about it struck me as flirting.
Afterward, she talked with a mutual friend, who then came over and asked why I was being an NPC. Fair criticism, perhaps, though I hadn’t realized my first party came with a performance review.
Later, we were sitting around talking as a group. She was on the floor because the couch was full, and I noticed her looking at me a few times. I’m awkward with eye contact, so I mostly avoided looking back. At one point, I’m pretty sure someone beside me offered her their seat.
When I first mentioned leaving, my matchmaking friend immediately said, “No, don’t leave yet.” His tone suggested I was about to miss something. I was tired, so the possibility of an event requiring my attendance wasn’t especially persuasive.
Eventually, I made my rounds and said goodbye. She followed me outside, told me she thought I was cute, and asked for my number.
Caught off guard, I said, “Yeah, sure.” A brief response with a surprisingly long aftermath.
As I walked away and she went back inside, I heard everyone cheering. Apparently, the party had been waiting for this development. I had been attending a social gathering; everyone else had tickets.
Now I’m worried about what happens if she texts. I like her as a person, but I’m not interested in dating her. Giving her my number probably suggested otherwise, even though I said yes because I didn’t know what to say in the moment.
I don’t want to hurt her or give her false hope. I’m also worried our mutual friends will think I led her on. How do I explain that I’m not interested when the last thing she heard was an entire room celebrating?
