For a while, my dating life came with a strong benefits package for everyone except me. I had a big circle of friends, including several women I found attractive, and I was available for advice, assistance, and whatever else needed sorting out. Romance was apparently handled by another department.
There were about 20 people in the group, seven of them women. As far as I could tell, none of those seven considered me someone they might date. I tried moving beyond friendship a few times. Those attempts did not require a second chapter.
I read dating advice. I tried things. Nothing changed. Then I came across an idea that stuck: perhaps I had become so committed to being helpful that helpfulness was practically my entire personality around women I liked.
That explanation appealed to me. It gave me something concrete to change, which was more useful than another evening wondering what mysterious ingredient I lacked.
So I started retiring the advice desk. If someone wanted my wisdom, I’d explain that I only gave bad advice. Printer trouble? Put it back in the original box and throw it out the window. A bold troubleshooting strategy, with obvious warranty implications.
An invitation to assemble IKEA furniture got a different response, too: What was in it for me? Would there be beer? I could still participate, but I no longer needed to arrive as a complimentary installation service.
At first, I had to watch myself. My instinct was to offer a solution before anyone had finished describing the problem. Making a joke instead felt oddly strenuous, considering how little practical value I was providing.
I thought the shift changed how the women in my circle saw me. Whether it was the teasing, the confidence, or simply having something to contribute besides answers, I couldn’t have separated the ingredients.
Three months later, the romantic picture looked very different to me. I won’t pretend I kept a spreadsheet. For once, I had found something more interesting to do than troubleshoot.
