I’ve asked a few friends what surprised them about the men they’ve dated. I also asked my ex-girlfriend, whose answer stayed with me because it was more specific than the question.
She had dated several men before me, as well as a woman. When she talked about those relationships, she described similarities, but the differences gave each person a clearer shape. Most of the men had been romantic, she said. They simply expressed it in different ways.
One man stood out as especially gentlemanly and romantic. Yet she also described him trying to restrict her private choices around pleasure and being unwilling to offer a kind of intimacy she wanted. She hadn’t enjoyed that part of the relationship. His romantic behavior hadn’t made that mismatch disappear.
Another man was nice to her but mean to other people. That detail caught my attention. Being treated warmly by someone gives you one experience of them; seeing how they treat everyone else can add information you wouldn’t get from the date alone.
She said most of the men had been good overall. Her account left room for affection and disappointment in the same person, which made it more interesting to hear. A word like “romantic” could describe several men without telling me very much about what dating each of them had actually felt like.
We dated when we were 20. We were busy, and our personalities were different. Our own relationship had its particular circumstances, too.
I’m a little cautious about asking this publicly. Around five years ago, I posted another question and received dozens of critical and insulting responses. I hadn’t expected that reaction, so I find myself wanting to explain what I’m asking before the conversation even starts.
I’m interested in individual experiences: the similarities you noticed, the differences you didn’t expect, and the things you only learned once you knew someone well. What surprised you about a man you dated that you wouldn’t have guessed from the first few conversations?
