Four women have turned me down in a short stretch, and I’ve started doing something I wish I could stop: treating each rejection as another piece of evidence about my face.
With two of them, there had been flirting while we were out. I even kissed one. Those moments made asking for a date seem reasonable. I wasn’t assuming a kiss guaranteed anything, but I thought there might be enough interest to see each other again.
Then came the vague replies. They’d let me know, or they’d turn me down gently. Nothing that gave me a date to look forward to. After the fourth time, I was no longer just disappointed about four separate women. I was wondering whether I’d misunderstood how attractive I was.
The confusing part is that I have reasons to think otherwise. Women have approached me before—about three times. I’ve had two girlfriends. My last girlfriend used to tell me I was very handsome, and when we walked through the city, she’d sometimes say other women were looking at me.
I believed her. Or at least I believed her enough that I wasn’t constantly trying to work out whether I was ugly. It was nice to walk beside someone who seemed so sure she liked what she saw.
Now those memories keep coming up against the recent rejections. I remember her compliments, then wonder whether she was simply being a loving girlfriend. I remember being approached, then start minimizing how often it happened. Somehow the encouraging parts of my dating history need supporting evidence, while the disappointing parts get accepted immediately.
I don’t know why these particular women weren’t interested in a date. Their replies didn’t come with explanations, and flirting only told me so much. Still, four close together have left me asking the same uncomfortable question: am I having a bad stretch, or was the confidence I had before based on something I got wrong?
