I started a friends-with-benefits arrangement with my best friend just after my breakup. At first, it was good. I was having fun, and being with someone I already knew made it easy to enjoy what was happening without turning it into another relationship.
Then I brought up something I was interested in: rougher elements, including choking and light BDSM. His reaction was immediate. He seemed alarmed, and the conversation became awkward enough that I backed away from what I’d said.
I told him it was a joke. It wasn’t.
That’s the part I keep coming back to. I had meant it, but once I saw his reaction, pretending otherwise felt easier than leaving the difference between us out in the open. The conversation ended with him hearing that I hadn’t been serious and me knowing I had.
He has his own comfort level, and his reaction made it clear that what I was suggesting wasn’t something he welcomed. I don’t want him doing anything he’s scared of. At the same time, the way things are now feels boring to me. It’s an uncomfortable mismatch to discover with someone who’s also my best friend.
I’m thinking about ending the arrangement. I haven’t done it yet, and I’m not sure how that conversation will go, especially after I brushed off the last one as a joke. But continuing means going back to something I’m already feeling restless about.
There was a good part, and I don’t have to pretend there wasn’t. I had fun. I got over my ex. Now I’m wondering whether that’s where this arrangement ends.
