Suppose I’m older, successful, and still in a marriage I want to keep. The relationship works. There’s a shared life worth protecting. But my wife wants sex less often than I do, and the difference seems to be growing. What am I supposed to do with the part of me that hasn’t slowed down?
That’s the question I’m trying to ask without dressing it up as a scandal. I’m imagining a situation, not claiming to know what happened in someone else’s marriage. From the outside, it’s easy to supply a tidy explanation for private behavior. Inside a marriage, I suspect the details are considerably less tidy.
My wife wouldn’t owe me desire because we’ve been together a long time. I also wouldn’t suddenly stop wanting closeness because acknowledging it had become inconvenient. Both things could be true while we stood in the same kitchen, discussing groceries as if there weren’t another conversation waiting behind that one.
The hardest part of the hypothetical is the timescale. Less sex this month is one thing. Imagining much less sex for the rest of my life feels different. I could love my wife and still grieve that possibility. She could love me and find the expectation of more sex exhausting. Neither feeling supplies a solution.
Even talking honestly would carry uncertainty. Would she hear that I missed her, or that I was keeping score? Would I be able to listen to her answer without treating it as the beginning of a negotiation? A conversation could clarify the difference without making it disappear.
Success wouldn’t give me much help here. Money and professional confidence wouldn’t make our desires line up. I’d still be one person asking another person for something she might not want.
So the question remains painfully ordinary: if we both want the marriage, but want different sexual lives, what could we willingly agree to—and could I live with the answer?
