I had a question about approaching someone at the gym, so I asked the internet. This gave people a chance to evaluate the approach before I had actually approached anyone. Efficient, I thought.
The situation I described was straightforward: suppose you’ve never made eye contact with someone. They may never have noticed you at all. Would walking over and introducing yourself make them uncomfortable?
That missing eye contact seemed relevant. There would be no shared smile to refer back to, no small acknowledgment that we’d noticed each other. From her perspective, I might simply appear, fully prepared to begin a conversation she hadn’t scheduled.
I wanted to hear from women, although I neglected to specify that in the original question. A useful detail to leave out when seeking a particular group’s opinion.
The women who answered gave me various versions of no. Different wording, broadly consistent reception. An introduction under those circumstances didn’t sound especially welcome.
I thanked them in an update. I probably needed to hear it, and they had answered what I asked. There wasn’t much point in requesting honest opinions and then trying to negotiate the results.
The question itself, however, was also getting downvoted.
That part puzzled me. I understood the answer about the gym. I was still trying to understand the reception to asking about it. Had the question sounded worse than I intended? Was this something people were tired of explaining?
I’d gone in wondering whether an introduction would be uncomfortable. I came out with a fairly clear answer, plus a smaller question about internet procedure: why was asking getting downvoted, too?
