After our first outing, we scheduled three more. To me, that seemed like a pretty encouraging development. I thought we’d enjoyed our first date enough to skip the part where we wondered whether there would be a second. Now she says none of those plans were dates at all.
I hadn’t been calling them that when I asked her. I said I wanted to “take her out,” which sounded clear enough in my head. Apparently, that phrase had more room in it than I realized.
There were other things, too. We’d look into each other’s eyes for a long time when we were together. If we ran into each other in a group, we’d catch each other looking. There was light physical contact. We were fairly reserved, so those small moments felt significant to me. I thought we were being cautious about something we both understood.
Then I actually used the word “dating.” I said a place was great for dating, and I made a joke about her dating a broke guy. Those comments felt casual when I said them. They turned out to be the beginning of a conversation I wasn’t expecting.
She started asking what dating meant to me. From my side, the questions began to feel like arguments, and we never managed to resolve those arguments very well. A couple of days later, she texted to say she wasn’t interested.
I heard what she said. What’s confusing is looking back at the time before that message. I had been so sure the interest was mutual that I wasn’t even wondering whether we were dating. I was thinking about where it might go.
Part of me wonders whether our unresolved disagreements changed things. Another part wonders whether I misunderstood the whole situation from the first outing. Those are different possibilities, and I don’t know which one she means.
I want to ask her to clarify, though I’m not sure what I’d actually be asking: whether she lost interest, or whether she never felt it in the first place. Would asking help me understand, or would she just have to tell me she isn’t interested again?
