I’d been on three really good dates with this woman. Enough to feel excited about seeing her again, though we weren’t exclusive and she wasn’t my girlfriend. I understood that there could be other people in the picture.
Last night, she told me she was going to a house party in another town. She even showed me the jackets and gloves she was going to wear. It was an ordinary conversation about her plans, with enough detail that I had no reason to wonder about them.
A friend was visiting me, so we went to a bar to get pizza. About five minutes after we sat down, she walked in with a guy.
They didn’t notice us. From what I could see, they were very obviously on a date. I’d gone out to spend time with my friend, and suddenly I was watching someone I liked have an evening she’d described to me as something else.
The other guy wasn’t the part I kept getting stuck on. We hadn’t agreed to stop seeing other people. She didn’t owe me exclusivity after three dates. But I couldn’t make the house party in another town line up with the two people in front of me.
My last girlfriend lied to me for years about an affair. That history makes this hard to sort through. I know how quickly an inconsistency can bring everything back, and I don’t want to mistake that reaction for certainty about someone I’m still getting to know.
We said hi on our way out. She seemed embarrassed and shocked to see me. It was a brief encounter, but it left me with more questions than I’d had while sitting at the bar.
Later that night, she texted to say she was embarrassed. I haven’t heard from her since.
Now I’m wondering whether I’ve spotted a warning sign or whether my past is making this feel bigger than it is. The text told me how she felt about being seen. It didn’t tell me what happened to the house party.
