My girlfriend and I had been together for two years and had just moved in together a week earlier. I was setting up Netflix on her tablet and transferring her watch list to my account when a WhatsApp notification appeared from a man I didn’t recognize: “Hey princess, long time no speak. I hope you’ve been behaving yourself… or not.”
I shouldn’t have opened the conversation, but I did. The messages went back to the early weeks of our relationship. They weren’t explicit sexting, but they were unmistakably sexual and flirtatious. One reply suggested he might get a better taste of her charm in person. I scrolled through other old chats and found similar exchanges with four more men, all from around that same period.
We had been dating for a while before we officially got together. She’d been honest with me about kissing someone, sleeping with someone, and sending someone else a nude before we became a couple. That had hurt, because I’d thought she wasn’t seeing other people in that way, but I accepted that we hadn’t yet made things official. What I hadn’t understood was that the flirty messages carried on after we did.
From what I found, the conversations stopped about six weeks into our relationship. We went on a holiday together soon afterward, and I haven’t seen any replies or new conversations with those men in the two years since. Some of them apparently kept messaging her, but she didn’t respond. I don’t think this is something she’s still doing, and I don’t have evidence that anything physical happened while we were together.
That should make the situation simple. It doesn’t. I had trusted her completely, and now I’m looking back at the things she said to me then and wondering what they meant while those conversations were happening. Maybe she was used to the attention and didn’t know how to step away from it immediately. Maybe there’s something I’m missing. I can’t know from a handful of old chats.
I don’t want to throw away two years together, especially now that we’ve just started building a home together. But finding those messages has left me feeling betrayed, and I can’t pretend they’re irrelevant just because they’re old. I’m still trying to work out what I believe about that first month—and what I want to do with what I’ve learned.
