I met a woman through a hookup subreddit, and for a while, things were straightforward. We started chatting, moved over to Telegram, and exchanged pictures. I was interested. The conversation was going well.
Then she casually mentioned that she was married and asked whether that was a dealbreaker.
That changed the conversation. Being married could mean a few different things in this context, so I asked the question that seemed most relevant: Did her husband know she was hooking up with other guys?
Her answer was, “I’m the open one. He closes an eye.”
I’ve been stuck on that sentence. I can understand what she might mean, but I can also imagine several versions of the arrangement behind it. Maybe he knows and accepts it. Maybe he suspects and avoids asking. Maybe that’s simply how she describes something he hasn’t agreed to at all. Her answer leaves room for every one of those possibilities.
The inconvenient truth is that I’m still keen. Finding out she was married didn’t switch off my attraction, and I’m not going to pretend it did. We’d already built up some interest before she mentioned her husband. That’s why this feels like an actual decision instead of an easy reason to stop replying.
But I don’t want to mistake my interest for evidence that everything is fine. So far, I have her explanation and no independent way to know whether it’s accurate. The person whose understanding matters here isn’t part of our conversation.
I also don’t want to walk into unnecessary drama because I accepted a vague answer that happened to suit me. If her husband has no idea, I’d be getting involved in a situation very different from the one I thought she was offering.
Nothing has resolved that uncertainty. I’m still interested, still having second thoughts, and still looking at the same question: Is her word enough to go ahead, or is this where I walk away?
