We met in college. We were two fairly average-looking people who became friends and started spending time together. She fell for me somewhere along the way. My feelings didn’t begin in the same place.
I got used to her being there. She became part of my everyday life, someone whose presence felt familiar and comfortable. I care about her. Eventually, we decided we would get married.
Nobody pushed us into it. There was no family pressure, no demand that we settle down together. Both sets of parents know about us, and everyone is more or less comfortable with the idea. We seem comfortable with it, too, at least from the outside.
For the past year, though, I’ve kept wishing I were with someone I found more beautiful. I’m ashamed even writing that. She looks good, and I’m not some exceptionally handsome man who thinks he’s entitled to a perfect partner. I have flaws of my own. Knowing that hasn’t stopped the thought.
What I keep imagining is a stronger physical pull—the feeling of looking at the person I’m going to marry and being overwhelmed by attraction. I wonder what would have happened if I’d waited, met somebody else, or experienced that feeling before agreeing to spend my life with someone.
It’s difficult to admit how much space an imagined person has started taking up. There is no actual someone else here, just a possibility I can’t test against everyday life. Meanwhile, the person who loves me is real. So is everything we’ve already built together.
She’s emotionally invested in us. Marriage has become the natural next step, and I’m still trying to understand whether my hesitation is ordinary doubt, immaturity, or something I shouldn’t carry into a marriage.
I’m scared of marrying her and spending years wondering who else I could have been with. I’m equally scared of losing someone who has loved me because I kept comparing her to a person who might not exist.
Our families know we plan to marry. She loves me. I care about her. And I still don’t know what to do.
