I met my girlfriend in college about three and a half years ago. She’s two years older than me, and at 19 I was already doing the math on every reason she might be out of my league. As we got closer, we started talking about our past relationships. She knew I’d had a serious high school girlfriend, and eventually we talked about our sexual histories, too.
She had more experience than I did. I was embarrassed that, although I’d been in a long-term relationship, I hadn’t had sex with that girlfriend. So I told my new girlfriend I had—and said I’d slept with three people total. In reality, I’d slept with two, and not with my high school girlfriend.
It was a stupid lie, but it didn’t stay a one-time thing. The subject rarely came up, and I never corrected myself. For the first year, I was still insecure. Later, I stopped caring about how little experience I’d had, but by then I’d gotten used to keeping the lie in place. Silence turned out to be an easy way to avoid an uncomfortable conversation. It also gave the lie a remarkably long shelf life.
We’ve been together for years now, and I can genuinely picture marrying her. That’s why I can’t imagine moving toward marriage while leaving this unspoken between us. What scares me isn’t the number itself; it’s that she may hear “I lied for years” and decide it says something fundamental about who I am. I want to explain that I was insecure at 19, not that I’m someone who lies easily—but I know that explanation could sound like an excuse.
I’m not worried she’ll somehow discover the truth. I just can’t keep carrying it around, especially as we start talking more seriously about our future. I don’t know whether telling her will damage our relationship or whether keeping quiet would be worse. I only know I need to come clean, and I have no idea how to begin.
