My girlfriend and I have been together for seven months, but we’ve known each other for almost two years. Before we became a couple, we talked on and off. Sometimes she was affectionate; sometimes she pulled away. I never quite stopped wondering about those stretches.
Eventually, I looked through her phone. It was a breach of her privacy, and I’m responsible for that. What I found has left me questioning the beginning of our relationship, even though I have no reason to think she’s been unfaithful since we became exclusive.
Last summer, she told me she was interested in me, and we went on three dates that month. In messages to a friend, she said she’d slept with an ex the night after our second date. She also wondered whether finding out would hurt my feelings.
The night before our third date, she was on a date with someone from Tinder. She told her friend about our plans for the next morning, joked about being messy, and later said she’d slept with the Tinder date. She asked whether she should tell me she’d gone out with someone else.
After our third date, she brushed off my attempts to arrange another. We stayed friendly and didn’t go out again until late last year.
Other messages showed that she’d continued seeing her ex for months. That ended around two weeks before we became exclusive, after she and I had already started sleeping together. I hadn’t known there was that overlap.
One exchange keeps bothering me. About a month before we started dating, a friend suggested she date the ex. Her response was that she didn’t think he wanted her as a girlfriend. Reading that, I started wondering whether she chose me because the relationship she wanted with him wasn’t available.
I know we weren’t exclusive during those earlier dates. I also know the messages don’t tell me everything she felt. Still, they’ve changed how I remember that time.
Now I need to ask her about it, which means admitting I searched her phone. How do I explain that I’m questioning whether she wanted me, while taking responsibility for how I found the messages?
