The detail I kept coming back to was the time: around 5:30 in the morning. Early in our relationship, while we were still long distance, I woke up and saw that my girlfriend’s location showed her heading back to her apartment.
She’d been out with friends. We’d been texting and talking on the phone throughout the night, so seeing her on her way home at that hour concerned me. I called her, and she said she’d fallen asleep on a couch.
I couldn’t quite settle into that explanation. Over the months that followed, she looked me in the eyes and repeatedly promised that nothing bad had happened that night. I wanted to believe her. We were building a relationship, and I loved her.
We’re both 32 and had been together a little less than a year when, this week, she finally admitted she’d kissed someone that night. She said that was all that happened.
I don’t know whether it was. Coming home at 5:30 doesn’t prove anything beyond coming home at 5:30. But after being reassured so many times, I’m having trouble accepting another version of the night just because she says this one is complete.
The admission also changed how I remembered everything that came afterward. Each time I’d raised the subject, she’d known there was something she wasn’t telling me. Meanwhile, I’d kept investing in us with the understanding that her original account was true.
I broke up with her and asked her to move out. That’s where things stand. I haven’t discovered proof of anything beyond the kiss, and I don’t want to pretend my suspicions are facts. What I do know is that she kissed someone and then repeatedly denied that anything had happened.
I still loved her when I made the decision. That hasn’t made the decision easier to sit with. I keep thinking about those conversations, how directly she reassured me, and how long I believed we were moving past a concern that she could have explained honestly.
Was ending it the right call?
