My boyfriend and I have been together for almost four years, and this is the best relationship I’ve ever had. I believe it’s the best one he’s had, too. I’m happy with him. That’s what makes my question about getting engaged feel both straightforward and surprisingly difficult to ask.
Sometimes I joke about when he’s going to propose. He always says, “When the time is right.” It’s an answer, technically. It just doesn’t give me much sense of what he’s waiting for.
I’m not in a huge rush to get married. I’m also not holding out for an expensive ring or an elaborate proposal. He works for himself, has a good job, and makes good money, but I’d be happy with a Walmart ring if it meant we were engaged. The price isn’t the part I care about.
What I’m trying to understand is the timing. I see couples get engaged after a year, and others stay together for ten years without getting engaged at all. Those examples don’t tell me what should happen in my relationship. They do make me curious about how differently people reach the same decision—or whether they reach it.
I’d especially like to hear from men who are married or engaged. When did you know you wanted to marry your girlfriend? Was it obvious within the first few months or the first year? Or did that certainty arrive slowly, after you’d spent much longer together?
I wonder what helped you know. Something about her personality? The way she treated you? How you felt when you were around her? Maybe there wasn’t a single moment, just a growing inability to picture your future without her in it.
Then there’s the gap between knowing and asking. Once you knew, how long did you wait before proposing? When my boyfriend says the time will be right, I can’t tell whether he’s waiting to feel sure or already feels sure and is waiting for something else.
