I’m 28, my girlfriend is 26, and we’ll have been together for five years this December. We’re long-distance, so we usually see each other once every month or month and a half. It’s not the easiest setup, but we’ve made it work.
My family knows about us. I’ve introduced her, everyone likes her, and they’d be happy to welcome her into the family. On her side, though, her parents still don’t know we’re together. Her father is strict, and she’s afraid to tell him.
There are other things she worries could count against us. I’m from a non-Brahmin family, while she’s Brahmin, and her father would prefer a son-in-law with a government job. I work in the private sector. I’m doing well and have a good salary, but I understand that may not settle her family’s concerns. She also works in the private sector.
For a while, I thought we were just waiting for the right moment. About a year and a half to two years ago, she said she’d tell her family once she got a job. She got one, worked there for a year, then moved to a better position. When I raised the subject again, she wanted time to settle into the new company. I understood and waited. It’s been about ten or eleven months since then, and we’re still in the same place.
Recently, I asked her directly whether she sees me as her future husband. She said she wasn’t sure about me because she didn’t know whether I’d stand by her if her family objected. I told her I would, and that I’d do my best to convince my own family too.
Then I asked what would happen if we tried for a year or two and her parents still refused. Would she take a stand for us? She said she couldn’t go against her father, couldn’t convince him, and didn’t want to compromise her position. From where I’m sitting, it feels like the expectation is that I approach him, do the persuading, and even put up with being humiliated if that’s what it takes. She isn’t ready to take on that responsibility herself. When I asked whether she’d still want to marry me if her parents never agreed, I couldn’t get a clear answer.
I’m not asking her to confront her father tomorrow, or even to have the whole family conversation at once. I’ve asked her to start by telling her mother, then take things one step at a time. I’ve also said I’m willing to give us another year or two and support her while she tries. But if we’re still in exactly the same situation after that, with no path toward marriage and no decision either way, I don’t think I can keep going indefinitely.
Even small arguments sometimes turn into talk of breaking up. With the future already so uncertain, those moments hit hard. I love her and have always pictured building a family with her. I’m not looking for someone else. But I’m 28, and I feel like it’s reasonable to want to plan my life rather than wait without knowing what we’re waiting for.
Am I expecting too much after almost five years? Is it fair to ask her to take some responsibility and give me a clearer answer, or should I keep waiting and supporting her? I’d especially appreciate honest perspectives from people who’ve been through intercaste relationships or similar family situations.
