One of the first things my Hinge date told me was that I was too pretty to be on a date with him. I thought he was cute, so this seemed like an unnecessary objection to his own evening. I told him not to be ridiculous and accepted it as a slightly awkward compliment.
I’m 32, he’s 35, and we spent about three hours together over several drinks. We had good conversation and the same sense of humor. He insisted on paying for everything. On paper, a perfectly promising first date.
In person, the compliments kept coming. He was amazed by how attractive I was. Then he was amazed that I was attractive and interesting. Apparently, finding those qualities in one woman required a moment of silence, although he didn’t take one.
I told him my friends were also hot and interesting. They are. I know plenty of women with both looks and personalities, and I wasn’t sure why I was being presented as a rare discovery.
He’s had multiple girlfriends whom he met organically, so he isn’t unfamiliar with dating. He has a good job, he’s athletic, and he’s outgoing. From what I could tell, this wasn’t simply a man who needed reassurance. I also don’t consider myself so spectacularly attractive that a three-hour response is required.
Eventually, I think he noticed I was uncomfortable. He assured me he was being genuine and suggested a pact: if we kept dating, we could wait a few months before doing anything physical. That’s generally my pace anyway, so I agreed. It was a considerate offer. The compliments continued.
By the time I got home, I felt overwhelmed. That surprised me because so much of the date had been good. I liked talking to him. I liked his humor. I just didn’t know what to make of someone gushing over me when we’d only just met.
My previous relationship involved a man who could barely produce a compliment under duress. Now the universe seems to have adjusted the settings without consulting me.
Was this first-date enthusiasm that got away from him, or something I should take seriously? I’m still deciding whether I want another evening together—with perhaps a little less time devoted to my face.
