I’m 46, and over the last two or three months, I’ve fallen hard for someone I wasn’t expecting to find. It feels mutual. He’s fond of me, we have the best time together, and being with him feels good in ways I find difficult to put aside.
He’s gentle and warm, with a masculinity I’m drawn to. He communicates well. He treats me with care and has my back. I feel fully seen by him, and when something matters to me, he’s my biggest cheerleader.
We share values. Our physical connection is wonderful. Where I live, meeting someone who thinks along the same lines can feel like a long search, so finding him has meant a lot.
He also wants ethical nonmonogamy. I don’t.
We’ve talked about it. He knows how I feel, and he’s said he thinks I really am enough for him. He might be willing to be monogamous in the future. But that isn’t where he is now.
I keep getting caught on that possibility. It’s hard to hear that something might change without making a little room for it in my plans. Especially when the person saying it is someone I already want to keep.
I’m his only deeply emotional connection. I wish that reassured me as much as it seems like it should. But knowing I hold that place doesn’t stop it from hurting that he wants to sleep with other people.
There’s a sentence I keep coming back to: he’s enough for me, and I wish I could be enough for him. He has told me he thinks I am. Still, the relationship available to me right now isn’t one I feel comfortable being in.
Because so much between us works, I catch myself searching for a compromise I could manage. Then I recognize something familiar: me preparing to put my needs aside because I don’t want to lose someone.
That’s a pattern I’m trying to change. I’ve been around long enough to know that agreeing to something painful doesn’t mean I’ll eventually stop feeling it.
I haven’t ended it yet. I know I need to, and I’m so sad. I wish I hadn’t fallen this far before understanding what staying would ask of me.
Is it foolish to walk away from someone who treats me so well when I know I can’t be happy with what he’s offering?
