At the beginning, the chemistry felt easy. I’m 35, he’s 37, and after three dates I thought we had something worth exploring. Then he ended it, saying his past was still troubling him.
Soon afterward, he reached out again. He wanted to see me. We made plans, and then he backed out. That became a pattern over the next two years: we’d lose contact, reconnect, start seeing each other, and stop again.
After we’d spent more time together and been intimate twice, he said we wanted different things. He only wanted something physical; I wanted a relationship. That sounded clear enough, except he continued coming back.
Eventually, we did become a couple. We traveled together, and he introduced me to his friends and family. There was an actual relationship to point to, with shared experiences and people who knew us together. For a while, the earlier stops and starts seemed like something we’d gotten through.
Sex remained difficult. He enjoyed the lead-up and some kinds of intimacy, but he struggled to maintain an erection during intercourse. He was also the one initiating. I could see that he wanted us to try, even when it didn’t go as he hoped.
After nine months together, he broke up with me. This time, he said he felt little lust or desire. He attributed the difficulties we’d had during sex to a lack of physical attraction to me.
That was painful to hear, especially after so many occasions when he’d been the one reaching for me. I’ve tried to understand his explanation without deciding I know more about his feelings than he does. But it’s hard to reconcile it with the relationship I experienced.
And he’s still reaching out. He calls, sends intimate photos and messages, and says he’s emotionally attached. He also continues to say his physical desire for me isn’t strong.
I don’t know what explains any of it. The calls keep arriving, carrying the possibility of closeness from someone who has already told me why he doesn’t want to be with me. After two years, I’m still trying to understand what he’s asking me to come back to.
