I’m already dreading Christmas, and the problem is a man who has been nothing but kind to me. He’s generous, he talks about a future together, and he can afford practically anything I might think to buy him.
We’ve only been dating a short time. I’m 52, with my own house, my own car, and a good six-figure job. On paper, I’m doing well. In everyday life, I pay attention to what things cost. Being thrifty is part of how I’ve managed to afford what I have.
He lives at a different financial level. When he talks about traveling together and staying in places I could never consider booking myself, he’s describing a life he’s used to. I’m hearing lovely possibilities, followed almost immediately by the question of what I could contribute.
I would like to treat him too. I’d like to buy him something special or take him somewhere wonderful without quietly working out what that would do to my budget. My salary doesn’t make his version of the good life affordable for me.
We haven’t been physically intimate, and I think he wants us to become exclusive and move the relationship forward. I’m hesitating, even though he treats me well. Part of me wonders whether he would be better suited to someone whose finances are closer to his.
He hasn’t been described by anything unkind in this story. The discomfort is mine: I don’t know how to receive this kind of generosity without feeling that I should be able to return it in the same form.
Christmas makes that feeling concrete. A gift is supposed to be a pleasure to choose. Instead, I’m wondering what could possibly feel special to someone who can simply buy whatever he wants.
I’d like to hear from people who have been on either side of this difference. When one person can afford so much more, what does giving back actually look like—and how did you get comfortable with it?
