I need someone to talk me out of this, because I can make a pretty convincing case against her and still find reasons to stay.
When we first met, she had a boyfriend but was interested in me. Instead of telling me that, she set me up with her best friend, apparently to get me out of the picture. I slept with her friend. Then, at a bar, she spent the night flirting with me right in front of her. Her friend got upset, they fought, and she came home with me. We made out while her friend was still sulking. It was messy before we were even a couple.
After that, she repeatedly cheated on her boyfriend with me, including sexual acts at work. We started dating two weeks after she and her long-term boyfriend broke up. I know that’s not exactly a reassuring beginning, and I wasn’t an innocent bystander in it.
Now she says she wants to move on from her ex, but she still keeps him close. They share a dog, so there’s a practical reason to stay in touch. But she also likes the attention and has trouble letting go. She didn’t really take time to heal from that relationship before we started seeing each other.
There are other things that worry me. She struggles to set boundaries and would rather keep people happy than be honest about what she wants. She buries her feelings and avoids being vulnerable; eventually, those feelings come out in unhealthy ways. Money is another concern. She spends without much of a plan while watching her savings disappear, and she has a $1,300 monthly car payment.
The problem is, I like being with her. The sex is great, we’re comfortable together, and the chemistry is real. I’m catching feelings, which is inconvenient when I don’t trust how she handles relationships—or hard conversations.
I can see the warning signs. I can also see all the reasons I keep answering her texts. Please convince me the good parts aren’t enough to make this a good idea.
