Yesterday, I caught my boyfriend cheating again. After two years together, and after already giving him another chance once, I blocked him everywhere. Now he’s sending emails, apologizing and asking me to let him try again.
For the past three months, he had been using another account to talk to women who showed interest in him. One was someone he used to describe as practically his sister. That detail keeps coming back to me: how ordinary and reassuring that description sounded before I knew.
I thought we were doing well. Whatever problems we’d had, I believed we were still choosing each other. Meanwhile, he was keeping this separate part of his life going, and I was supporting him without knowing what was happening.
Somehow, I often ended up feeling that my support wasn’t enough. I could be there for him and still come away wondering what else I should have done. Finding out about the account has made those conversations feel different.
I made a mistake in May. I’m not pretending otherwise, and I’m not trying to erase my part in our problems. But he keeps bringing it up as the explanation for why he changed. I didn’t know that while I thought we were working through things, he was hiding three months of conversations.
He could have left. It would have hurt, but I never forced him to stay. Instead, I kept trusting someone who could look me in the eyes and act as though everything was normal. Now I’m wondering how much of what I felt between us was actually shared.
I loved him. That’s the part that doesn’t disappear just because I blocked him. I want someone who supports me, someone whose affection I don’t have to keep doubting. Right now, it’s hard to imagine trusting anybody enough to build that again.
I don’t want to date, and I don’t want to give him another chance. I already know what it took to trust him the last time. His apologies are arriving by email now, asking for something I don’t want to give.
