Three months into dating my boyfriend, I’m considering ending things over an airplane neither of us is currently looking at.
I’m 25, he’s 29, and we met on Hinge. We hit it off quickly. During one of our first phone calls, back when we were doing a little long-distance dating, we started listing interesting things about ourselves. His contribution was that he’d never seen an airplane in the sky.
He’d seen planes at airports. He’d been on a plane. He just claimed never to have seen one flying.
We live in a city with one of the busiest airports in the country. Seeing a plane here requires roughly the same preparation as seeing a parking meter. You go outside.
Naturally, I assumed he was joking. I went along with it, figuring that eventually we’d be outside together, a plane would pass overhead, and I could point. A modest plan. No equipment required.
Unfortunately, our dates hadn’t given me much opportunity. I don’t handle the cold well, so we’d mostly stayed indoors. I tried suggesting daytime walks in our free time, but something always came up. The joke remained unchallenged by field research.
Then we went to a potluck on a day when, for reasons I wasn’t entirely clear on, flights across the country had been grounded. A friend I’d told about his claim remarked that now the whole country knew what it was like to be him.
At some point in the conversation, I said he was joking. I don’t remember exactly how we got there. Nothing seemed wrong at the party.
When we got home, he told me he hadn’t appreciated my dismissing his experience as a joke. It felt bad, he said, to know I didn’t actually trust him.
This was where I lost track of the performance. If there was a performance. His voice was flat enough that I couldn’t tell whether he was genuinely upset or extending the bit into a discussion of our relationship.
Since then, I’ve asked him more than once to clarify. He keeps saying things like, “If you’re not going to believe me then don’t bring it up please.” Sometimes he says there’s no trust in our relationship.
I want to respect a request to drop something. I would also like to know whether I’m being asked to respect a sincere claim or participate indefinitely in a joke whose rules I haven’t received.
At first, I wanted to catch a plane passing overhead. Now I don’t especially care whether he’s seen one. I’m tired of trying to work out when he means what he says, then getting nowhere when I ask.
I still like him, which makes this difficult to explain. On paper, breaking up over a possible running gag sounds ridiculous. In practice, the gag has lasted about as long as the relationship, and I’m no longer enjoying my part in it.
I haven’t ended things. I keep wondering whether there’s a way to clear this up without turning it into an ultimatum. But I’ve gone from wanting to point at an airplane to wanting out, and I still can’t tell whether he’s kidding.
