Usually, disappointment does a useful thing for me: it kills the crush. First I get angry. Then, somewhere along the way, I stop wanting the guy. I don't necessarily enjoy the process, but at least I recognize it.
This time, I'm still waiting for that second part.
We'd known each other for a few months, flirting over text and in person, before anything really happened. Then we went on two and a half dates over three weeks. I don't know what else to call the half. It wasn't much of a dating history, but by then I'd already spent months liking him.
During those three weeks, he was seeing someone else. He essentially lied to me about it twice. Meanwhile, when we were talking about another guy he'd seen me with, he asked, “That other guy doesn't matter anymore, right?” I keep coming back to that question, considering what he wasn't telling me about his own situation.
He also made a point of telling me I wasn't a “hottie,” only a “cutie.” I still went on the second date. That's an awkward detail to include, but leaving it out would make me sound much more easily put off than I apparently was.
Then, after what seemed to be another lie about what he'd been doing the day before, he stopped replying. Almost immediately, he started posting about other girls on social media, where he knew I could see it. There wasn't much room to mistake the silence for a promising development.
That was a month and a half to two months ago. I've had plenty of time to remember the parts I didn't like. The trouble is that I still think about him constantly, and remembering those parts hasn't stopped the crush.
About a week ago, I saw him again. I couldn't help talking to him. We ended up talking and flirting for a while, and afterward I wanted to see him again. Not just to have some satisfying final conversation. I wanted to try things with him again.
It's embarrassing to admit how much I enjoyed that conversation after everything that came before it. I can list the reasons I was hurt, but when he's in front of me, I still like talking to him. Then I have to go home with both of those things.
This might be the biggest crush I've ever had, which feels like a ridiculous distinction to give someone I went on two and a half dates with. But it is what it is. I really, really like him.
I keep wondering whether it would be stupid to try again. Even as I ask, part of me is hoping I'll get to see him.
