We met while traveling. We’re both in our thirties, and I still managed to get swept up in her in a matter of days. Early on, she told me she was staying at the home of a guy she’d casually hooked up with. He’d gone away and offered to let her stay. Then she and I found out we were headed to the same island next, and she asked if I wanted to spend our time there together. I said yes right away.
The guy was coming home that evening. She said she didn’t especially want to see him but felt like she probably should, since he’d lent her his place. She told me she’d stay at a hostel. For reasons I still can’t explain, I took the ferry a day early. We hugged and kissed at the pier, talking about how good it would be to see each other the next day. I spent that night alone in the hotel I’d booked with the two of us in mind, wondering why I’d been in such a hurry to leave.
When her ferry came in, she ran straight into my arms. Just like that, I felt silly for having spent the night worrying. We took her bags back to the hotel and started kissing. In between kisses, I asked where she’d ended up staying. His place, she said. I asked if they’d slept together. She said yes.
We’d never slept together ourselves. She told me she wanted to take things slowly with me and see where it went. With him, she said, it was purely physical. She also pointed out that we hadn’t agreed to be exclusive, and she was right. I could follow everything she was saying. I kept thinking about those twelve or so hours, how I’d lain awake thinking about her, and how differently the night had gone for her.
We’re still together. It happened a little while ago, and I still get hung up on how sure I was, standing on that pier, that we were both looking forward to the same thing. I’d like to hear how it lands with other people, especially women. Is it understandable that it still hurts? How much of that hurt comes from an expectation I’d made without ever saying it out loud?
