My coworker’s favorite dessert is chocolate chip cookies, and his birthday is coming up. I’m thinking about baking him some. This would be a simple sentence if I hadn’t also had a huge crush on him for the past year.
I’m 26, and he’s turning 35. We work together, which is the part where sensible people tend to stop reading and start shaking their heads. I know. Coworkers are supposed to be off-limits. I have had plenty of time to become familiar with this policy.
I’ve tried to get over him. The crush remains employed.
Now I’m considering whether homemade cookies might be a cute, low-key way to show him I like him. I know something he enjoys, I could make it for his birthday, and the gesture would be personal without requiring me to deliver a speech. On paper, this seems manageable. There would at least be something to do with my hands.
The problem is that cookies are also just cookies. People bake them for neighbors, coworkers, fundraisers, and anyone standing near the kitchen at the right moment. He could be delighted with the gift and receive absolutely none of the information I was hoping to include.
I can imagine thinking I’ve made a bold romantic gesture while he thinks someone has correctly remembered his preferred dessert. Both interpretations would be supported by the evidence.
Then I worry about going too far in the other direction. Is baking for him sweet, or a little dorky? Does a birthday batch say I pay attention to you, or does it say I own baking sheets? I would prefer the former, although the latter is easier to establish.
I haven’t baked anything yet. I’m still trying to work out whether this is a reasonable hint after a year of liking him, or whether I’m expecting chocolate chips to handle a conversation I’m reluctant to start. If I give him the cookies, will he get it—or will he simply have a very good birthday snack?
