Sometimes I notice my boyfriend and one particular friend of his are online at the same time, and I immediately wonder whether they’re talking. Nothing has happened on my screen except two people using their phones. Somehow, that’s enough to get me started.
Before we dated, she sent him pictures of herself in bikinis. I also saw messages that felt flirty to me. He acknowledges that, but says he has never been attracted to her and has always considered her a friend.
His sister has reassured me too. She apparently asked him directly whether he could ever be interested in this woman, and his answer was absolutely not.
The confusing thing is that I believe him. I don’t secretly think he’s waiting for an opportunity to leave me for her. Yet knowing about those earlier exchanges makes their friendship feel harder to relax around than his other friendships.
She encouraged him to go to the gym, play sports, and stay active. Those are things he enjoys. Instead of letting that be an ordinary positive part of his life, I sometimes turn it into a comparison: did she bring out something in him that I don’t?
He knows the friendship makes me uncomfortable. We’ve argued about it, and now I sometimes worry he has stopped talking to her just to avoid upsetting me. That possibility doesn’t make me feel better. I don’t want him managing his friendships around my reactions or feeling he has to hide an innocent conversation.
Then I see them online together again, and I want to ask.
I can follow the whole thing through logically. Being online at the same time doesn’t mean they’re messaging. Messaging wouldn’t automatically mean flirting. There could be a perfectly ordinary conversation, and I would still feel that tug to know about it.
We’ve already talked about this enough for me to recognize how tiring another request for reassurance could become. I don’t want every uncomfortable feeling to turn into something he has to answer for.
What I’m struggling with is the space where I don’t know. How do I see those two online indicators, feel the familiar urge to check, and actually leave it there—without spending the rest of the evening pretending I’m fine?
