I’ve been seeing this guy for about a month. On our second date, we got talking about books, and I lent him my copy of The Secret History because he’d never read it. A perfectly normal beginning to what has apparently become a minor literary dispute.
He returned it last weekend, and I noticed little pencil comments all through the margins. Some were reactions to the story, some were jokes, and a few were questions aimed directly at me, like, “Do you actually agree with this?”
He said he thought it would be fun for us to go through the notes together over coffee sometime. I genuinely love that he put so much effort into reading a book I recommended. I also have to ask: who writes in someone else’s book without asking first? It’s not a rare collector’s edition, but I’ve had it for years, and apparently I am more attached to its margins than I knew.
My friends are split. Some think it’s romantic; others think it’s presumptuous. I like him and don’t want to make a big deal out of something he clearly meant as a nice gesture. So now I’m stuck between “thoughtful book-club flirting” and “sir, this is my paperback.”
