My friend Andy’s save-the-date is on my fridge. I love his fiancée. I love my boyfriend. We go on double dates, talk about our futures, and look like four people whose lives have worked out nicely.
And I still wish I’d kissed Andy when I had the chance to find out what might happen.
I’m 28 now, and he’s 30. We met at work in our early twenties, back when we were part of a bigger group. People asked if we liked each other, and we both said no. At first, I meant it. As coworkers left and the group drifted apart, we kept showing up for each other. We hung out after work and met each other’s friends, always as friends ourselves.
Somewhere along the way, my weekend plans started revolving around whether I’d see him. If he invited me out, I’d say I already had plans with my friends but maybe we’d meet up later. Then I’d spend the evening trying to steer my friends toward his bar. Apparently, a direct yes was beyond me, but organizing an entire group’s night around him was fine.
I talked about him constantly, including on dates. I even tried setting him up with one of my best friends. She deserved a great guy, and the best guy I knew was Andy. Somehow, that thought didn’t prompt any further investigation.
A group trip finally made it impossible to ignore. I saw him without a shirt and realized, very suddenly, that friendship wasn’t all I wanted. We were affectionate on that trip, but we were also drinking a lot. I told myself that explained it and that everything would feel ordinary once we got home.
It didn’t.
We texted more. We FaceTimed more. He came to the things I invited him to and started dropping by my apartment for no particular reason. I noticed every casual touch. Looking back, I wonder whether he was interested too, but I never asked. At the time, I could explain away anything. He was my closest guy friend. Being wrong felt like it could cost me something I couldn’t replace.
After about three months of this, an old high school friend asked me out. I decided it was time to move on from a man I apparently wasn’t going to do anything about. Andy gave me a little more space while I was dating someone, and I tried not to read into that either.
The new relationship lasted a month or two. We weren’t a good fit. Then a concert I’d planned to attend with Andy and some other friends came around, and all the feelings I’d tried to put away came right back.
Afterward, we went to a bar. Andy was drunk; I was sober. At one point, I was standing between his knees with my hands on his shoulders, laughing. I thought we might kiss. I wanted it to happen, but neither of us made a move. Our friends called us over to play pool, and the moment passed.
He was tired by the time we finished, so I told him he could sleep on my couch. We held hands on the walk to the car. He fell asleep in the passenger seat on the way home, still holding my hand. That night, I went to bed thinking I might finally work up the nerve to ask him out.
The next morning, while I drove him home, we talked about an upcoming friend’s party. He mentioned that he was bringing a woman he’d been seeing for a month. He wanted everyone to meet her.
I hadn’t even known she existed. I acted delighted and said I couldn’t wait. Privately, I hoped it would turn out to be a few dates that went nowhere, like the ones I’d had.
Then I met her. She was funny, smart, kind, and pretty. I liked her immediately, which made my secret hope feel even worse. They became serious, and with every month they stayed together, I had less room to pretend I was waiting for my turn.
Six months later, I met my boyfriend. He checks all the boxes I used to hope someone would check, and he treats me like being with me is the best thing that’s happened to him. I love him. We’re talking about marriage too.
Andy and I are still close. His fiancée makes him happy, and I’m happy that he has her. None of that is something I have to fake.
But I keep going back to that trip, those visits to my apartment, the bar after the concert. I wish I’d told him how I felt while we were both free to have that conversation. I don’t know what he would have said. I might have been disappointed. We might have had an awkward few weeks and stayed friends.
Instead, I never asked, and now I’m in love with someone else while carrying around a question about him. My boyfriend deserves better than a part of me still wondering. I know that, and the thought hasn’t gone away.
The save-the-date is still on the fridge. I’m looking forward to their wedding. I wish I could look at it without remembering the night before I found out about her.
