When my boyfriend told me a woman had messaged his fitness account asking for a free workout plan, I barely thought about it. He’s a personal trainer with around 500 Instagram followers. He said he should start charging for requests like that, and I assumed the conversation would either end there or become work.
We’d been together for two and a half years. Things had been rocky recently, but we were still together, still trying. I didn’t think a workout request was something I needed to follow.
Yesterday, he showed me her profile. He followed her from his coaching account and his personal account, where they’d been chatting regularly. When I asked, he said she’d followed him first and that they only talked about fitness.
Then I asked whether she knew he had a girlfriend.
He said he’d told her the day before, when they met. That was how I learned they’d met.
They’d been messaging for more than two weeks. In the chats I saw, he’d talked about himself and his family. She’d sent gym pictures and personal photos with her sister. She complimented his looks and hair; he thanked her. None of that proved an affair, but it was more personal than the fitness conversation he’d described.
While I was reading, he pulled his phone away and blocked her. He said she meant nothing to him, that he wasn’t interested, and that blocking her was the only way he could prove it. I was still trying to understand what had happened.
Later, he insisted they hadn’t really met: he’d only collected prasad, religious food, from her, and the exchange had taken about five minutes. The distinction mattered to him. To me, it was still an in-person interaction I hadn’t known about.
He says mentioning me hadn’t come up before then. I asked whether our rough patch had made him reluctant to say he was taken. He denied it. He kept returning to the fact that he eventually told her.
I don’t have confirmation of physical cheating. I’m unsure whether emotional cheating is the right description, either. What I know is that he shared personal details with her while leaving me unaware of how much contact they had. He thinks blocking her settles it. I’m still stuck on the moment he casually said, ‘when we met,’ and wondering where we go from here.
